Please, please, please tell me where you disagree. I want to know where folks think I'm way off base and why. The purpose of these postings is not to explode my opinion on the world, but to engage in a discussion with other authors over what makes a speculative poem worthy of "best of the year". If people disagree, I want to hear it and know why. Even if the end result is simply agreeing to disagree, it's still worth having the discussion. I look forward to reading your responses!